Why I Hate Overstock.com

I have been amazed to read about how many people love this site.  Twice now we've ordered the same rug, and twice we've been sent the wrong one.  This past time I got an e-mail saying the item I had requested was back in stock.  There was one of them.  We assumed that the first time ours got sent to the wrong person and they sent it back.  So I immediately ordered it, though it cost more the second time than it had the first (they had given us a $50 credit because of the issue, after going higher and higher up the chain of command, originally we were offered nothing).  Today I stayed home to wait for it to be delivered.


It's the same pattern, the wrong colors.  The one I ordered was dark grey and light grey.  Instead we got the grey and black one.  No problem right?  Except the black and grey one has a brown tone to it that will not work in our home.  See?

Right Rug

Wrong Rug

Now the customer service hasn't even been as helpful (we're waiting on a call back).  At first they didn't even offer to come and have the rug picked up, we were going to have to drive it to a UPS store.  Second, they aren't offering any sort of compensation, and the $50 credit from before will be put back, but for what?  Please someone explain to this company why I would not want to shop with them again, since apparently they aren't getting it.  You've screwed up twice, your customer service has been even less helpful, and so why on earth would I try ordering anything from you again?  We'll end up using our $50 credit on something for exactly that amount, no more, and never using this site again.  

I am envious of those of you who have good experiences with this site.  This has only been the second time shopping with them, but I'm making sure everyone I know knows what has happened and that they aren't worth much when it comes to customer satisfaction.  If you've had problems with them as well, please let me know......I feel like I'm in some sort of disappointing home decorating twilight zone.